Showing posts with label Indian Muslim - Dilemma. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Indian Muslim - Dilemma. Show all posts

Saturday, February 20, 2010

Why should a Muslim have to wear his nationalism on his sleeve?

We owe the young Muslim our trust, due process and the benefit of the doubt — so that when the horror of something like Pune happens, he can spontaneously share the revulsion of his fellow citizens without the insidious taint of guilt by association, writes Najeeb Jung.

Sixty-three years ago as Nehru spoke of India's tryst with destiny, millions of Muslims rejected the Two-Nation theory and made their choice to stay in the motherland. India was their "madare watan" and India it was where they would live and die. When people questioned their integrity and commitment to the nation and suggested they were fifth columnists, they bore the calumny patiently.

The '50s and '60s were difficult years marred by a sequence of riots where often enough Muslims were at the receiving end. Even the pluralist Nehru's commitment to a secular politics wasn't enough to curb the police's tendency to visit retribution disproportionately on Muslims in the wake of a riot. Misled by the platitudes and promises of the political elite, Muslims remained a community bereft of leaders. But a quarter of a century after partition, attitudes changed. Young Muslim boys and girls left behind the sense of alienation and exclusion that had beleaguered their parents. The partition of Pakistan in 1971 and the foundation of Bangladesh was a landmark event that gave this new generation of Muslims the strength to speak in a more modern, secular voice and to stand up for their rights, their place in the Indian republic.

Today, despite sectarian tragedies like the razing of the Babri Masjid or the Gujarat pogrom, the young Muslim is very much part of the system. He has a confident sense of shared citizenship and wants to exercise his rights. What upsets him is the tired rhetoric of "Muslim alienation", the condescending op-eds encouraging him to merge himself into "mainstream" society, to contribute to Indian's burgeoning economy which seem to assume that he has spent his life in a backwater or another planet. He is tired of being stereotyped. He is a regular guy, who works for a living, thinks the same thoughts and nurses the same ambitions as the great Indian middle class that the world is justly celebrating. And so like Faiz he wonders: "Iss raah pe jo sab pe guzarti hai who guzri Tanhan pase zindaan kabhi ruswa sare bazaar Garje hain bahut sheikh sar-egosha-e-mimbar Kadke hain bahut ahle hakam bar sare darbar" (I go through all that one goes through while on this path At times alone in jail, sometime defamed in the bazaar The sheikh denounces me from the pulpit And the ruler lashes out at me in his durbar).

I work at a remarkable university where young boys and girls and grown men and women who truly represent India's diversity, give the lie to these divisive stereotypes. They hang out together, eat and drink together, see movies together and party together. Their thought processes, their aspirations are shared. They dress alike, they want similar jobs, they look for love and laughter, new friends, wider horizons. Like young people everywhere,they want to move on.

So when the horrors of Mumbai and Pune occur, and he hears the same cliches - Muslim alienation, local Muslims supporting Pakistani terrorists, the disgruntlement in Muslim youth after 9/11 and so on - he's gripped by that depressing deja vu. Once again Muslim men and women will be asked to wear their nationalism on their sleeves, be more vehement in their criticism of Pakistan than their non-Muslim fellows, to demonstrate their credentials as citizens.

If this patriotic Muslim citizen were to point out that in the aftermath of the Mecca Masjid blasts in Hyderabad, scores of young Muslim boys were yanked out of their homes, then either to be released after weeks of torture when there was no evidence to hold them or to disappear without trace, some columnist or pundit would comment on the defensiveness of the Muslim middle-class, or muse that educated Muslims were in denial. A single' encounter' in Batla House, New Delhi, located in a Muslim majority area is enough to put 'Muslim society' on notice and a sophisticated modern central university, with an unmatched nationalist lineage under a cloud. The alleged complicity of a serving army officer in a terrorist plot didn't lead people to conclude that the army or 'Hindu society' was violent or disaffected; it would be useful if the same benefit of the doubt were extended to those of this republic's citizens who happen to be Muslim.

But here's the thing: young Muslims understand the piquant situation they are in. After all, there is truth to the charge that an earlier generation of Muslims asked for a separate homeland and got it. They know they belong to a proselytising religion; they are aware of the flourishing myth that Islam gives no quarter to 'kafirs'. They know that Islam is misunderstood by non-Muslims and often misinterpreted by their co-religionists. They're self-conscious about the controversy regarding Muslim polygamy, the stereotypes about jihad, the promised hooris in heaven, the hideous penal practices of certain 'Muslim' states, the barbaric instances of inhuman behaviour by the likes of Mullah Omar in Afghanistan, the blasphemous justification of such behaviour by invoking the Nizam-i-Mustafa.

He knows that the violence practised by extremists makes the task of explaining Muslim belief and practice hard. With suicide bombers in the headlines, who cares to know that suicide is forbidden in Islam? Verse 195, The Cow, and verses 29-30,the Women, clearly state: "And spend of your substance in the cause of Allah, and make not your own hands contribute to your destruction; But do good." Every Muslim theologian will tell you that suicides are haram. Who wants to know that in practice having more than one wife is impossible because the conditions laid down for marrying again are so exacting, when people see manifestly imperfect Muslim men marrying again. Which non-Muslim will feel the resonance of Islam's assertion that all men are equal, when he or she can see Muslim states where Muslims are more equal than others, and Muslim men more equal than women?

The young Muslim in India is aware of all this. He struggles with regressive interpretations of his faith in his own life and he is completely integrated into the socio-economic fabric of India. Years ago, a friend in the IPS, Rashid Khan produced a film called the Seventh Man. His hypothesis was that every seventh man in Calcutta was a Muslim. But he was so integrated into Calcutta that his efforts and energy moved the economic wheels of the great city.While he was not rich, he worked at jobs without which the city would be dysfunctional : as a baker, a weaver, a barber, a butcher. Today's young Muslim has greater ambitions than that. He wants to start a business, be an engineer, do an MBA. He anxiously awaits campus recruitment, he crams for the UPSC exams and dreams of the civil services. Others want to be judges, lawyers, dentists and doctors, some want to be active politicians.

Each one of them is aware of the numerous handicaps he faces, the hurdles, the prejudices he is likely to encounter, the shortcomings in his own community, its inherent backwardness, poverty, lack of modern education, lack of a youthful leadership. And yet he wants to overcome all this and be part of this great nation that his parents chose to stay behind in, to be share in the promise Nehru held out on the midnight of 15 August 1947: he wants to be part of this nation's tryst with destiny. What we owe him is trust, due process and the benefit of the doubt: so that when the horror of something like Pune happens, he can spontaneously share the revulsion of his fellow citizens without the insidious taint of guilt by association.

Thursday, February 18, 2010

Minority safety in India

Need for Equitable Representation of Minorities in the Administration of Indian Government
Mirza A. Beg
The essential requirement of good governance in a country is the welfare of all its citizens. This is the paramount ideal of constitutional democracies. India is a constitutional republic based on a very good and robust constitution.

The first duty of the Indian government is to protect the life and liberty of all its citizens. Everything else pales in comparison. Endemic sectarian riots rob the beleaguered communities. It dehumanizes and polarizes the majority as well as the minority. India has been rocked by cyclical sectarian riots for decades with increasing partisanship of those in power. With the burgeoning information technology, India has unprecedented opportunity and is on an upward trajectory to find its rightful destiny. The endemic poverty of a majority of its citizens and the fear of life by many minorities is an enormous drag, impeding progress.

Many, weak secularist though lightly infected with sectarianism take shelter and find justification in a myopic view that India is better than many other countries. It is true India is a better democracy than many. India's record is even better, considering the size and tremendous diversity of the population. But simply saying that we are better than others does not wish or wash away the problems. It certainly does not help the nation, particularly the suffering poor and the minorities at the receiving end of the stick.

Baser human instincts propel many, to smugly justify what is advantageous to them and find the reverse reprehensible, if advantage accrue to others. Societies and nations do better when this tendency is on the decline or enough people stand up for the downtrodden. India has a better record than many other countries. Many great souls, particularly from the majority community have sacrificed a lot to stand up for justice for those perceived to be "the others". Sectarianism of the majority is much more injurious to the nation than the minority sectarianism, because in a democracy minorities do not have the power of numbers to drive the agenda.

Free press should be and is a boon, but it becomes a bane when ordinary decent citizen inundated with insidious propaganda absorbs sectarianism (communalism in Indian parlance) without realizing it. Half truths from anecdotal stories are circulated to fortify sectarianism. Democracy has a self corrective mechanism, when enough thoughtful people rise up to negate such misuse and help protect the minorities from the clutches of entrenched sectarian interests. Fortunately many from the majority community in India have taken up this necessary burden.

Sectarian forces use perceived anecdotal injustices to spread their propaganda. Systematic discrimination and oppression that creates a deprived underclass can only be determined by rigorous social scientific research. In India the constitution itself made special provisions for the long suffering down-trodden casts and tribes (Scheduled casts and tribes) to overcome the horrible disparities and systemic exploitation of millennia. When such constitutional remedies are used some very deserving individuals of upper casts have felt cheated. That is what happens when we think of people as groups.

The case of grouping Muslims and Hindus as groups has many pitfalls, because they do not form homogeneous groups. But in the last six decades, because of endemic sectarian riots a large proportion of Hindus and Muslims have polarized and coalesced into a sectarian consciousness.

In order to design a solution based on well researched statistical data from the government archives and dozens of judicial enquiry reports into cyclical sectarian riots the Government of India established a committee under Justice Sachar. An exhaustive and comprehensive "Sachar Committee Report" came out in December 2006. It deals with the consequences of the endemic sectarian riots, destruction of lives and property and systematic discriminations against a large minority of Muslims and recommends temporary reservations in government employment for Muslims to compensate for the decades of discrimination.

Many object to sectarian reservation, suggesting that help should be based on economics parameter, taking into account individual circumstances. Religion or cast based reservations are not a panacea and have built in resentment. I sympathize with this view, but experience has shown that individuals, especially those at the bottom of the ladder have no power to get redress from systematic discrimination. The only way though imperfect is to implement the policy for the discriminated groups. Larger numbers provide vigilance in implementation of a policy.

The solutions are not simple, but some redress is imperative otherwise, India will continue sliding down the spiral in the sectarian abyss. Fortunately there are two trends to the advantage of India at this juncture.

First is the fast expanding Indian economy due to the technological revolution and the globalization. In a limited economy, for some to get redress others loose, but in an expanding economy it is easier to share, except for those whose ideology is based on hatred of others.

Second. No government can or should try to micro engineer every facet of life on the basis of perfection in equality. It will fail under the enormous weight of bureaucracy. In the burgeoning fields of sciences, education and research meritocracy ought to rule and profit motivated fast expanding private sector can not afford not to employ the best and the brightest. It is in the realm of the governing power where some parity is needed. Inequality in governance, such as police powers, justice dispensation and licensing of industries is not only deleterious, but it has been lethal, as proven time and again in endemic sectarian riots. Based on the judicial inquiry reports and disproportionate number of victims from the minority communities the injustice becomes obvious.

Why the representation of Muslims in administration is pitiful? No great intellectual prowess or great qualification is needed to be a policeman, a city clerk, or a low to mid level administrator. The judiciary at the district level must have judges represented from all communities to avoid blatant miscarriage of justice. Experience has shown that these are the levels where the most damage is done to the impoverished powerless communities. If different communities have approximate parity in these jobs, sectarian riots will not occur, or if they do, they will be very short lived, because the culprits will have a much better probability of being brought to justice.

Fortunately the Supreme Court of India has been a beacon of responsibility and Justice. One reason could be that they are in the lime light. It was the Supreme Court, the court, the court of last resort that was able to put breaks on Mr. Modi's pogroms in Gujarat. Though the sectarian influences have kept him in power, but his murderous ways have been checked. There are now documented evidences of the culpability of the Gujarat government under Modi using the state machinery of power. That is why the events in Gujarat have been classed as pogroms rather than riots by most non sectarian observers.

The essential responsibility of a government is to safeguard its people from the enemies. Foreign enemies are easy to recognize, it the domestic enemies who injure the constitution and the national fabric. They are more dangerous and pose an existential challenge to the nation. The sectarian rioters are the domestic enemies. They can be curbed if the government really wants. There are glaring examples within India. Bengal, particularly Calcutta was prone to communal rioting in the 1960s. Since the advent of the communist government in Bengal the sectarian riots have all but vanished.

Should there be limited reservations in above mentioned jobs? I feel uncomfortable with the idea. Besides religion and politics when they are directly connected, they make an explosive mix and it solidifies the identity separation. The government should make effort to bring about equity in essential services among many better defines smaller subgroups among all communities. It will avoid major cleavages based on religion. Many minor cleavages tend to cancel out each other. It is good for the people and it is good for the country.

If the government does not succeed soon in designing programs similar in spirit as the "Affirmative action" in USA, I am afraid the reservations, a much less desirable remedy until a reasonable approximation to parity is achieved will be needed by default. By limiting reservations to administration of justice, police, army and low level bureaucracy will leave the rest of the burgeoning private enterprise open to meritocracy.

A government that can not safeguard the lives of its citizens fails in its primary purpose.

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Indian Muslim - Dilemma

HUMRA QURAISHI


Things has come to such a pass that the majority perceives the Muslim as some devil at work


Steady doses of communal poisoning have been getting unleashed finding their way into psyches ever since LK Advani undertook that rath yatra that culminated in the destruction of the Babri Masjid . More dents on psyches and forms , and more doses of communal propaganda unleashed before and after the Gujarat pogrom of 2002.Onslaught has been on at two levels - actual rioting and killings , and then those communal slants and biases in governance , in policing . I see a hopelessly gloomy picture .Sharp divisions brought along rather systematically .It just about suits the fascist and right wing forces at work.

Yes , there are fears and suspicion of the so called 'other'.The majority sees the Musalmaan as some devil at work. For, together with that earlier concocted image of him or her producing like rabbits or tearing off 'gosht' with alarming frenzy , there are more concoctions along the newly done - up image of the Musalmaan of this country - of his terrorising people and throwing bombs. Of late, I have been hearing people say this and more in so many ways -these musalmaans can kill ,can throw about bombs …these bloody terrorists …all Muslims …only Muslims , only Muslim names ! " .

Till about two years back I had heard similar snide comments in Ahmedabad but now even here , in this capital. But, then , it's not really surprising because that's how those manning us are going about doing their shoddy job. .For one , even before the 'caught ' someone ( if not killed in some fake 'encounter ' ) is found to be a terrorist there's not just a hood or an Arab head - scarf thrown around his face but he is even paraded as a dreaded terrorist .All this done rather too subtly or even so very directly ! .No ,there are no footnotes attached .Maybe the caught /arrested someone is totally innocent, yet stands framed.

Even before an investigation gets started or even before charges thrown at him he is declared a terrorist. By a police force that today prides itself in getting a "tip off" from the Gujarat police with a track record not really fitting in the democratic fabric. Ask anyone with a secular outlook and he'd know the communal twists the police is so very capable of coming up with … And with that that bunch of Muslim names - Atif , Arif , Rahman , Amin , Sajid echo and re-echo all around …yes ,all around , floating on the television screens and lie splashed on the front pages .

Not to overlook the comments churned by some of those former ministers and bureaucrats ,who find time to sit through those television programmes and come up with nothing better than go about more than hinting that its people from the "other community " who are responsible for these terrorist attacks .Nothing short of rather blatant communal slants and more. In fact , in the last few weeks I have heard former Union Home Secretary K .Padmanabhaiah come up with these nauseating one liners - " all from the other community" and I have also heard former Home Minister ID Swami utter "only Muslim names coming up " . If day and night this sort of propaganda goes on , it's bound to creep in , its bound to seep into our psyche .The Musalmaan will not only be viewed with hatred and suspicion ,but after each blast the accusing finger will automatically get moving towards some him. Needless to add that then it will lead little probing as ground work along a particular pattern has been well laid out …And with that the Musalmaan will either sit like a second class citizen as he does in states like Gujarat or quite obviously, elements of deep fear and insecurity are bound to creep in .


Surely and rather steadily this trend has been on , being going on right from the early 90s .And now its reached much beyond ….So much so ,that it's about time the Human Resource Development Ministry or the Minorities Ministry ought to interfere and put a stop to this sort of blatant labeling . Didn't many politicians cry hoarse in the Arushi Talwar murder case , along the strain that its unethical and grossly unfair to throw about accusations before the caught person is convicted.But here , in these recent cases the situation gets compounded and complex because of the communal twists getting churned every other day .Situation is grave .It's serious because the very secular fabric lies twisted and turned about , in some hopeless manner. And the offshoots would be dangerous to contain .

Apologies for once again dragging in the tragic Arushi Talwar murder case but just ponder on the offshoots the case could have gone through and subjected to if the Talwars were separated, divorced or were Bangladeshis, Nepalese or Afghans here .But why drag yourself all that way? What if they were Kashmiris from the Valley or from the Northeast? New dimensions could have been worked upon! And quite simply gulped down so very readily by all of us , because of the popular perceptions in vogue , because the communal twists and slanted notions are bound to have an effect on the naïve us …

The very mindset is getting so very systematically tuned to think along the pattern that bomb blasts can only be done by men from a particular minority community .And with that in the foreground or background it's rather convenient to ' catch ' hold of people on this basis or kill them in those called encounters .And whilst you catch hold of these , the actual culprits could be sitting atop high chairs or be planning the next round on how to go about bringing divisions and more along the strain …making further inwards , further destroying the very fabric of this land.

And those of you who want to experiment on how it feels to be in a that or this category go about in a burqa and if you are a man then don a sherwani and put on a beard .Grow one. Or borrow one from any of the rightwing men who are said to be using camouflaging tactic! Just last fortnight I heard two very prominent citizens of this country recount some of those startling facts in this manner .

At a meet at New Delhi's Constitution Club , Pune-based Justice BG Kolse Patil remarked that security agencies overlook the role played by Sangh outfits .He brought to light that " beards , skull caps and other disguise motifs have been unearthed in RSS workers ' homes ! For what! Or those karkhanas getting unearthed …karkhanas for making of bombs ! " In fact , at this same meet ,a former DGP Gujarat RB Sreekumar , told a packed audience that during the 2002 pogrom , Sangh outfits in Gujarat would chant slogans ' yeh andar kee baat hai , police hamare saath hai !' " Imagine , it's the same Gujarat police which is busy directing the police in other states. And last week, activists Ram Puniyani and Shabnam Hashmi have drawn up this list where Sangh outfits were found to be making bombs and more.

I quote Ram and Shabnam: " …While the current investigation is totally focused on SIMI, many alleged culprits have been put behind the bars, despite which now some unknown entity Indian Mujahideen seems to have been projected as being responsible for the current ones. At the same time another stark truth is being deliberately sidelined and undermined. And that relates to the blasts carried out by Bajrang Dal and Hindu Jagran Samiti. We fail to understand as to why the investigation authorities are turning a blind eye to some of the well established facts…"

The list has the names of places where Sangh outfits were caught making bombs - Nanded, Vashi, Panvel and Ratnagiri in Maharashtra , Tamil Nadu's Tenkasi , Uttar Pradesh's Kanpur, …the list is long but , then , it seems rather baffling why these terrorists are not paraded as terrorists! Along with those terrorists who are terrorising the entire Christian population! Why these double standards ! Why this unjust and unfair system of governance?

This does not account for the double standards at work, at the very level of governance. At the very basics of governance ! There are so many unanswered 'Whys'. Why doesn't the percentage of Muslims and Christians in the police force and in the IB and CID match their population ratio? Why is the percentage of the jailed Muslims more than their percentage in the population? Why do we pass verdicts from our air-conditioned dens? Why do we brand and generalise along religious lines? Why aren't all those in the rightwing outfits terrorising the Christians , branded as terrorists and paraded right here? Why can't they be booked for treason and terrorism? Why is today's establishment unaffected by this steady degeneration our society is going through? Where's our investigative journalism? Where's our sensitivity? Where's our non-partisan attitude? Where's our basic sense to realise where we are headed? Is there disaster awaiting us?


 


Posted on Oct 31, 2008